Agua Caliente Band of Cahuilla Indians Water Rights Settlement Act
Download PDFSponsored by
Rep. Calvert, Ken [R-CA-41]
ID: C000059
Bill Summary
Another exercise in futility, courtesy of our esteemed lawmakers. Let's dissect this mess, shall we?
**Main Purpose & Objectives**
The Agua Caliente Band of Cahuilla Indians Water Rights Settlement Act (HR 5935) claims to aim for a "fair, equitable, and final settlement" of water rights disputes between the Agua Caliente Tribe, the United States government, and various other parties. Yeah, right. The real purpose is to grease the wheels of crony capitalism, while pretending to address tribal water rights.
**Key Provisions & Changes to Existing Law**
This bill is a laundry list of favors for special interests:
1. **Ratification of Agreement**: Congress rubber-stamps an agreement between the Tribe, Coachella Valley Water District (CVWD), and Desert Water Agency (DWA). Because who needs actual oversight when you can just sign off on whatever deal was cooked up behind closed doors? 2. **Tribal water right**: The bill establishes a tribal water right, which will likely be used as leverage for future negotiations or litigation. 3. **Settlement trust fund**: A slush fund is created to "settle" claims and cover costs associated with the agreement. Expect this fund to be raided by opportunistic politicians and their cronies. 4. **Funding**: The bill authorizes funds for implementation, which will likely be squandered on bureaucratic overhead, consultant fees, and other forms of waste.
**Affected Parties & Stakeholders**
1. **Agua Caliente Tribe**: They'll get some water rights and a settlement trust fund to play with. 2. **Coachella Valley Water District (CVWD)**: CVWD will likely benefit from increased control over water resources and access to federal funds. 3. **Desert Water Agency (DWA)**: DWA gets to join the party, too, with its own slice of the pie. 4. **Taxpayers**: You'll foot the bill for this boondoggle.
**Potential Impact & Implications**
1. **Water rights**: This bill will likely lead to further disputes and litigation over water rights, as other tribes and stakeholders demand similar treatment. 2. **Crony capitalism**: Expect a surge in lobbying activity, campaign contributions, and backroom deals as special interests jockey for position. 3. **Environmental concerns**: The agreement may prioritize short-term economic gains over long-term environmental sustainability. 4. **Taxpayer burden**: This bill will add to the national debt, further straining an already-overburdened system.
In conclusion, HR 5935 is a classic example of legislative theater: a feel-good bill that accomplishes little while enriching special interests and perpetuating crony capitalism. The real disease here is the corrupting influence of money in politics, which this bill only serves to exacerbate.
Related Topics
Sponsor's Campaign Donors
Showing top 5 donors by contribution amount
Donor Relationship Network
Interactive visualization showing donor connections. Click and drag nodes to explore relationships.
Showing 10 nodes and 0 connections